Print this page
Thursday, 25 June 2020 04:45

Solving California's Pension System Political Problem (w/ Steve Greenhut & Steve Green)

468x60

Steve Greenhut, Western region director at R Street Institute and author of "Plunder: How Public Employee Unions are Raiding Treasuries, Controlling Our Lives and Bankrupting the Nation," joins Mike Green of Logica Capital Advisers to discuss his coverage of the political paralysis that surrounds the issue of pensions in California. He guides Mike on a deep-dive into the gargantuan public employee compensation complex and how that complex bleeds into every other aspect of California government spending. He argues that public employees have forced state and local governments into a corner wherein they cannot maintain their obligations because of the massive burden of pension disbursements and employee compensation. Due to a lack of transparency, pension assumptions based on guesswork, and legal precedent overturning democratic decisions, Greenhut says that the perfect storm that will surely "surprise" Californian politicians has been plain to see for longer than a decade. Filmed on February 6, 2020 in Sacramento, California.

Video Transcription:

  Solving California's Pension System Political Problem (w/ Steve Greenhut & Steve Green)

 

MIKE GREEN: What is required to change the political problem? Can it be done on an individual voter basis? Can we all say no, as you suggested that you do? Can we all vote a new generation of leadership in? What is required to affect that political change? STEVE GREENHUT: Well, a lot of people have been working on changing the politics of California and to no avail from what I see. I don't know, I don't think anything's-- I really don't, I'm not trying to be nattering Neva, but I don't think anything will change until there's a fiscal crisis that precipitates change. That's what happened last time. The state shaved its budgets because it just didn't have any money. I remember it was Pennsylvania with some mayor who cut pensions I believe it was. This was in Wilkes-Barre or somewhere around. MIKE GREEN: Hazleton. STEVE GREENHUT: Yeah, it was somewhere in northeast Pennsylvania. Public employees sued. I think that-- I'm doing this from memory so I think they won and then I just remember the mayor saying great, I still don't make money. When you get to the point where it's like, great, I still don't have any money, something will have to be-- MIKE GREEN: No, no, that was Scranton, but yes, you're right. Nothing was solved. We still didn't have any money. It does feel like this is a situation that can't be resolved without suspending some element of the political process. That's what worries me most about it. I know that you have libertarian leanings. It sounds like this is going to have to boil down to an executive decision, whether that's a judge in a bankruptcy case, or whether that's-- STEVE GREENHUT: Like in Detroit, where they had-- or did they have a-- I didn't follow it that closely, I followed Stockton closely, but not Detroit that closely. They had a receiver. MIKE GREEN: They went into receivership. STEVE GREENHUT: Well, I don't think that that speaks to libertarianism one way or the other. If an entity is insolvent, you have to come up with a way to deal with it. Yeah, I don't know. I'm not a big guy on political solutions. MIKE GREEN: You're a reporter at heart. STEVE GREENHUT: Well, no, I write about it. I've dealt with so many people like, oh, here's the pension reform movement. It's a Doggett group and you've, ,in this series here, I know you're talking to some of them. There's some of the smartest people I know and they are working extremely hard at it and trying everything and I see local pension activists in San Jose, who, okay, that's an overwhelmingly democratic city and voters, thereby almost 70% of the vote approved a very significant pension reform and that the Democratic mayor, Chuck Reid, he's a great guy. He led that. I remember once I interviewed him, and I said, so was this something this easy? He looked at me and said, Steve, none of this has been easy. It was hard work. They got overwhelming Democratic majority on the council and in the city to approve pension reform. Then the union sued, and the courts throw it out. In San Diego, the city there, they did something different. They wanted to avoid the California rule problem. They came up with a way to reduce pensionable pay, the pay they can deal with, and that would reduce the pensions, and then they did a few other reforms that were all-- none of it ran afoul the California-- Anyway, the state agency, the PERB, the Public Employment Relations Board, they tossed it out, so you just can't win and you can't win in the legislature. What do you do? MIKE GREEN: Well, and even within that, as you know, we were talking to John Moorlach earlier, he managed to get legislation passed through the two houses to require transparency, electronic transparency of the budgets, XBRL markup, and Gavin Newsom vetoes it. What can be the possible rationale for why he would veto something that actually provides transparency to a process? STEVE GREENHUT: I've seen a lot of transparency bills die over the years because the effective groups don't want transparency. When I had talked earlier about those city officials who came to the CalPERS meeting, they were dealing with a John Moorlach proposal at the time. John, he had proposed some-- it was some Transparency Initiative. That's what they were about, and CalPERS rejected it. Yeah, it's better if we don't know what's going on, and we just trust that them and that's their attitude, it seems. Yeah, you can't get any. John, if you sat down with John, he could fix the whole pension problem in 10 minutes, and then spend the rest of his life and our lifetimes trying to get it through. That's the problem. It's a political problem. I don't know what the answer is to political problems. MIKE GREEN: Yeah. Unfortunately, those who have watched my episodes in the past know that my biggest concern is that we have a stalled political system and that we will ultimately force a non-democratic solution through and pensions tend to be the flashpoint at which the crisis occurs. Most democracies that experience pension crises don't emerge as democracies. Somebody has stepped in in an authoritarian way to solve the problem. STEVE GREENHUT: I haven't thought about what that end result would be, but I look at Washington and okay, we have republicans now and they're spending even more than the previous group of Democrats so it's just, to me, it looks like a two groups arguing over how you spend, it seems to be if Space Forces and military bill dogs, they cost a lot of money too, and all this social welfare programs and Medicare for all, I don't see anybody calling for fiscal responsibility and up in the State Capitol, there all sorts of spending proposals and so the folks up there seem to be content spending as much as they possibly can, you can't have a budget deficit in California and taxing as much as they possibly can. We see on the March ballot, Prop 13 has no relation to the 1978 historic Prop 13 that capped property taxes but this one would-- it's a bond. It's just a school bond, state school bond, but it would increase the debt limit at localities. Local school districts will be able to start passing more bonds and then in November, we're going to have a split roles, which would split away commercial properties from the Prop 13 tax protection. That's another, that's a union backed thing. That's just would be a massive influx of money. I don't see any end to their appetite for taxing and then it just can't tax enough.

Last modified on Wednesday, 01 September 2021 14:53
Add a Comment!“We encourage you to join the conversation! If you have any questions, ideas, or thoughts related to this article, Please Leave a Comment Below!
 

MORE DOCUMENTARIES

Forex Mastery: Multimillionaire Trader’s Journey - Documentary
Feb 28, 2024 161

Forex Mastery: Multimillionaire Trader’s Journey - Documentary

Embark on a captivating journey into the world of forex trading with our exclusive content, “Mastering Forex: Insights from Jeff's Multimillionaire Journey”. Delve into a comprehensive analysis of… ⤜More⤏
25 Million Pounds - BBC Documentary
Oct 20, 2021 1452

25 Million Pounds - BBC Documentary

25 Million Pounds Documentary details the collapse of Barings Bank in the mid 1990s primarily by a broker called Nick Leeson, who lost $1.3 billion by speculating on futures contracts. The film… ⤜More⤏
Meltdown: The Secret History of the Global Financial Collapse
Apr 29, 2023 1891

Meltdown: The Secret History of the Global Financial Collapse

It travels the world - from Wall Street to Dubai to China - to investigate the secret history of the global financial collapse. It tells the story of the bankers who crashed the world, the leaders… ⤜More⤏
INSIDE JOB (2010) documentary
Jul 16, 2021 1138

Inside Job - 2010 Documentary

INSIDE JOB (2010) Documentary is the first film to expose the shocking truth behind the economic crisis of 2008. The global financial meltdown, at a cost of over $20 trillion, resulted in millions of… ⤜More⤏
Hidden Secrets Of Money
Aug 07, 2021 4216

Hidden Secrets Of Money - All Episodes

Hidden Secrets Of Money is a groundbreaking new Doc-series hosted by Mike Maloney, monetary historian and author of the world’s best selling book "Guide To Investing In Gold & Silver". Mike’s goal is… ⤜More⤏
Cryptopia: Bitcoin, Blockchains and the Internet Future
Jan 19, 2024 252

Cryptopia: Bitcoin, Blockchains and the Internet Future

Dive into the heart of the digital revolution with “Cryptopia Unveiled: Bitcoin, Blockchain, and the Internet's Next Frontier”. This comprehensive exploration delves into the intricate world of… ⤜More⤏

Comments